Sherlock Holmes (PG-13) (2009)

“Elementary, My Dear Watson,” seems to sum up the depth of thought attributed to this 21st century adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s titular character. Once thought of as the poster child for deductive reasoning, Robert Downey Jr.’s interpretation of Sherlock Holmes is quite stylized, leaning away from pure logic and bordering on gadgetry. Jude Law’s Dr. Watson is refreshingly witty, clever and handsome, clearly not the rather stodgy, accommodating sidekick we have become accustomed to seeing with Holmes. However, though not the traditional Holmes and Watson, the good news is that Downey and Law make a fine team as an inventive pair of detectives in their own right.
The action is an entertaining, fast paced, but not a pensive, rendition of  the classic series. The plot itself is a bit fuzzy around the edges, but engaging enough to be forgiven by the audience. Not an original by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the story borders on the occult. A new nemesis, Lord Blackwell, caught by the duo and executed by the authorities, then returns from his grave to wreak havoc on London once again.
Director Guy Richie is successful in keeping the 19th century flavor of the setting, while updating the adventure to please modern tastes. Two ladies add a new dimension to the story of the famous detective duo. Rachael McAdams is Irene Adler who pits her wiles against the reasoning of Dr. Holmes in a love-hate relationship.  Kelly Reilly is Mary, the lovely and patient fiancée of Dr. Watson.
More bells and whistles than previous Holmes films, but it’s an amusing romp with two fine actors who are obviously enjoying their time together. 3